Home > Vehicle and Road Accidents > Can I Still Sue If Police or Insurance Say I Was At Fault For A Car Accident In Ontario?

Can I Still Sue If Police or Insurance Say I Was At Fault For A Car Accident In Ontario?

1

Yes. You may still have a personal injury case even if the police report or your insurance company says you were at fault for the accident.

After a crash, many people assume that once a police officer or insurance company assigns fault, the issue is settled.

That is not always true. A police report is important, but the officer typically did not see the accident.  Often the police report is just a collection of what the drivers and other witnesses said about the accident.  More and more, collision reports are done by the drivers themselves at collision reporting centres.

For many accidents it is obvious who is at fault.  For others, the analysis is more nuanced.  In Ontario, fault doesn’t have to be all or nothing either, it can be shared.

Police motor vehicle accident reports typically list the at-fault driver as “Driver 1”.  That said, the reports are sometimes incomplete or mistaken.  Fault determinations arising from complete reports with no mistakes still aren’t necessarily the gospel truth.  At the end of the day, the police officer’s opinion as to who is at fault is just that:  an opinion.

Does An Insurance Company’s Fault Decision Determine My Personal Injury Claim?

Insurance fault decisions are also not the final word in a personal injury lawsuit. In Ontario, insurers often rely on the Fault Determination Rules, found in R.R.O. 1990, Reg. 668, when deciding fault for property damage claims (e.g., when they determine whether you have to pay the deductible for your vehicle damage).

These rules set out various accident scenarios and assign fault percentages.  For example, they determine how fault is allocated between drivers for certain rear-end, lane-change, intersection, or parking-lot collisions.

The Fault Determination Rules are not the same as a court’s analysis in a personal injury lawsuit. They are used by insurers to determine fault for insurance purposes. They do not automatically decide whether you can sue, whether another person was negligent, or whether you are entitled to compensation for your injuries.

Most lawsuits settle, even if there is disputed liability.  If your lawsuit does not settle, a judge or 6 jurors look at all the evidence and decide whether a driver’s conduct fell below the standard of care expected of a reasonable driver.  They do this based on their own knowledge of driving, the rules of the road, and common sense.  There is no reference to the fault determination rules.

Can Both Drivers Be At Fault For A Car Accident in Ontario?

Real-world facts may be more complicated than the insurance fault decision suggests. One driver may have ran a stop sign, but the other may have been speeding.  Perhaps the accident was caused by Driver A’s breach of the rules of the road, but Driver B could have avoided it if he was sober. 

Poor road maintenance, missing signage, or mechanical issues may also have contributed to the accident.

It is also important to keep in mind that a successful injury claim considers not only how the crash happened, but also your injuries and losses.  Ultimately, the value of a lawsuit is measured by the severity and extent of your injuries and losses. Those losses may include pain and suffering, income loss, medical expenses, rehabilitation costs, and future care needs.

If the police or your insurer says you were at fault, do not assume your claim is over. That opinion may matter, but it does not necessarily decide your legal rights. The evidence should be reviewed carefully before you accept an insurer’s conclusion or walk away from a potential personal injury claim.

What If I Am Completely At Fault For The Car Accident?

Even if you are at fault, anyone injured in a motor vehicle accident can still make a claim for accident benefits.  Accident benefits are no-fault benefits – meaning they’re paid to injured folks regardless of who is at fault for the accident.

Injured In An Ontario Car Accident? Understand Your Legal Options

Call us today if you’ve been in an Ottawa accident where fault is unclear, or perhaps misattributed by the insurer or police.  We’d be happy to take a look at your case.

Contact Bergeron | Clifford LLP

Let us help you if you have been injured anywhere in Eastern Ontario. Contact us at 866-384-5886 or fill out our online form. We can meet at any of our office locations, including Kingston, Ottawa, Whitby, Carleton Place, Perth or wherever is most convenient for you.

Insurance Tactics

This article, hosted by the American Association of Justice, shows us how some insurance companies unjustly deny claims, discriminate by credit score, delay payments until death, and employ other tactics to make sure they make the most profit as possible, […]

Bergeron Clifford Takes the Gold!

Bergeron Clifford is proud to support Kingston Literacy by participating in the 15th Annual Grate Groan Up Spelling Bee. The Bee took place on May 17th, 2009, at the Ambassador Hotel, which is a new venue for the event. Team […]