Bergeron Clifford LLP Menu
Request your free case assessment today –
call: 877-391-2923 or use our

Experts: Helpful or Hired Guns:

In any personal injury file, both the plaintiff and defence will hire experts to help them prove various aspects of their case. Different experts can be hired to comment on, for example, the severity and likely prognosis of the plaintiff's injuries, how those injuries impact the plaintiff's ability to work and take care of themselves, and how much money the plaintiff is likely to lose over their lifetime because of the injuries. There is nothing wrong with this, of course, and it happens in almost every case. In fact, without an expert(s) to comment on these various areas, a plaintiff's case will not be very successful. For the defendant (or, really, the insurance company that pays for their defence and any judgment that might be awarded against them by a jury), experts are required to counter, if possible, any expert opinion hired by the plaintiff.

The credibility of the expert is, therefore, of utmost importance. After all, in a so-called "battle of the experts", you would prefer it if your expert was more credible and believable before the jury than that of the other party. In fact, the law requires that experts remain completely impartial and recognize in writing that their obligation is to the Court (and not the party hiring them) to provide an independent and unbiased opinion.

In practice, experts are often hired repeatedly by the same party and often fail in their obligation to be independent and impartial. Concerns arise when a particular expert starts tailoring their evidence to fit the theory of the case belonging to the party that hires them. In other words, they become advocates for the party hiring them, as opposed to independent and impartial witnesses whose only obligation is to help the judge and jury understand the issues.

Furthermore, because expert evidence can be very compelling in the eyes of a jury, the dangers arising from the evidence of an "advocate" or "hired gun" expert are compounded if the opposite party cannot properly show to the judge or jury that the expert is just that, a hired gun.

In this vein, you would think that one very persuasive way to show the biases of an expert would be to cross-examine him/her on past court cases where the expert was found to be un-credible because he/she was too biased or partial in favour of the party that hired them.

Unfortunately, and surprisingly to many, the laws of evidence, as they presently stand, prevent this type of cross-examination. In other words, you cannot cross-examine an expert on the fact that he/she was either disbelieved or found to be un-credible by another court.

So - what is a plaintiff to do when the insurance company representing the Defendant hires an expert they feel is more of an advocate than an independent and unbiased witness?

In the recent case of Daggitt v. Campbell, in advance of trial, the defendant wanted to call a particular expert witness (a psychiatrist) and brought a motion before the Court to appoint that witness to do an independent examination of the plaintiff. However, the Plaintiff was able to argue that the expert proposed by the defendant should not be appointed because of the nature of his expertise (he was a psychiatrist when the plaintiff's expert was a psychologist). Further, the motion judge had trouble with the expert's history. Numerous previous courts had commented negatively on the proposed's expert's credibility. The motions judge expressed reservations that the expert would therefore be able to testify at trial in accordance with his obligations to the court. This is a helpful (and original) decision which, in the future, could prove very useful in weeding out the "hired guns".

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information
Chat

What Our Clients Say About Us:

“From my first meeting with Mr. Bergeron and Mr. Clifford I was reassured, made comfortable with the legal processes involved and well looked after. Mr. Bergeron and Law Clerk, Craig Cameron were always available to answer questions and guide me through the legal procedure. I was fortunate to be able to work with a wonderful lawyer, whose abilities I have extreme confidence in.” – S.M.
“From my first meeting with Mr. Bergeron and Mr. Clifford I was reassured, made comfortable with the legal processes involved and well looked after. Mr. Bergeron and Law Clerk, Craig Cameron were always available to answer questions and guide me through the legal procedure. I was fortunate to be able to work with a wonderful lawyer, whose abilities I have extreme confidence in.” – S.M.
“From my first meeting with Mr. Bergeron and Mr. Clifford I was reassured, made comfortable with the legal processes involved and well looked after. Mr. Bergeron and Law Clerk, Craig Cameron were always available to answer questions and guide me through the legal procedure. I was fortunate to be able to work with a wonderful lawyer, whose abilities I have extreme confidence in.” – S.M.

Contact Bergeron Clifford LLP If you or a loved one has suffered an injury, contact us at 877-391-2923 or fill out our online form below. With office locations across the East Region and a clientele that often has mobility issues, we are prepared to work wherever is most convenient for you. If you need us to visit you at your home or hospital, we can do that too.

We can help you. Get started now

Bold labels are required.

Contact Information
disclaimer.

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an lawyer-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.

close

Privacy Policy

Visit One of Our Conveniently Located Offices Today Schedule your free appointment: 877-391-2923

Kingston Office
1 Hyperion Ct.
Kingston, ON K7K 7G3

Toll Free: 877-391-2923
Fax: 613-384-0501
Kingston Law Office Map

Ottawa Office
185 Somerset Street West, Suite 305
Ottawa, ON K2P 0J2

Toll Free: 877-391-2923
Fax: 613-241-6381
Ottawa Law Office Map

Whitby Office
173 Brock St. N., Suite 104
Whitby, ON L1N 4H3

Toll Free: 877-391-2923
Fax: 905-426-8574
Whitby Law Office Map

Perth Office
31 Foster St.
Perth, ON K7H 1R5

Toll Free: 877-391-2923
Phone: 613-267-4313
Fax: 613-267-4852
Map & Directions

Carleton Place Office
164 Bridge Street
Carleton Place, ON K7C 2V7

Phone: 613-257-5887
Fax: 613-257-5889
Map & Directions

We can help you. Get started now »