Bergeron Clifford LLP Menu
Request your free case assessment today –
call: 877-391-2923 or use our

A Brief History of No Fault

Craig-Cameron.jpg

No fault insurance originated in Great Britain and was originally termed 'knock for knock'. This is probably a better term than no fault to describe what the originating insurance companies wanted.

'Knock for knock' sprang from a desire by insurance companies to control claims expenses, not so much the damages that arose out of the claims and at first was basically a way for insurance companies to limit disputes amongst themselves.

'Knock for knock' in the simplest sense was an agreement in which companies would agree between themselves not to pursue subrogated claims against each other.

What is this subrogated claim you might ask. If you have ever made an insurance claim on your car, home or personal property you have had to sign a form known as a 'Proof of Loss'. (IBC 2) The Proof of Loss contains a clause allowing the insurance company to step into the shoes of the policy holder after he, she or it has been indemnified. This means that the insurance company is free to try to recoup what it paid as the claim from any other party that may have been at fault for the loss.

As you can see with vehicles this could be quite problematic in that a) disagreements between companies could arise over who is at fault, b) the actual value of the damages, c) whether company A's policy pays for things not covered by B etc. All these disagreements and discussions consumed a significant portion of adjusting time and resources thus limiting the amount of claims an individual adjuster could handle. The development of special subrogation units relieved some of the file handling pressure from the front line adjusters however resources still had to be allocated and costs incurred. Eventually through actuarial studies and other no doubt highly detailed cost benefit analysis the companies found that the law of large numbers would enter into the picture.

The law of large averages or a bell curve distribution is an easy way to visualize the insurance companies' claims. In some instances company A would damage company B's client. Prior to 'knock for knock', B would ask A to pay for the damage it did and the arguing would ensure. The shoe would be on the other foot in another instance so company B would be paying company A. With large numbers of claims the companies found that things would even out and then they could forego any subrogation issues without any significant reduction in recoveries while at the same time reducing the need for subrogation adjusters. A reduced claim expenses would follow.

If it is called 'no fault' how can I be at-fault? No fault does not mean what it says. There is always fault apportioned in any motor vehicle accident. Fault goes from 0% to 100 %. Within the physical damage (knock for knock) portion o f the claim adjusters use a fault chart (a simple set of diagrams outlining who is at fault and what percentage given different scenarios) to determine the apportionment of fault. Factors such as weather, road conditions and any other factor are not taken into account when determining fault under the fault chart, strictly driver action. Thus arguing with your adjuster that the roads were slippery is a road to nowhere.

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information
Chat

What Our Clients Say About Us:

“From my first meeting with Mr. Bergeron and Mr. Clifford I was reassured, made comfortable with the legal processes involved and well looked after. Mr. Bergeron and Law Clerk, Craig Cameron were always available to answer questions and guide me through the legal procedure. I was fortunate to be able to work with a wonderful lawyer, whose abilities I have extreme confidence in.” – S.M.
“From my first meeting with Mr. Bergeron and Mr. Clifford I was reassured, made comfortable with the legal processes involved and well looked after. Mr. Bergeron and Law Clerk, Craig Cameron were always available to answer questions and guide me through the legal procedure. I was fortunate to be able to work with a wonderful lawyer, whose abilities I have extreme confidence in.” – S.M.
“From my first meeting with Mr. Bergeron and Mr. Clifford I was reassured, made comfortable with the legal processes involved and well looked after. Mr. Bergeron and Law Clerk, Craig Cameron were always available to answer questions and guide me through the legal procedure. I was fortunate to be able to work with a wonderful lawyer, whose abilities I have extreme confidence in.” – S.M.

Contact Bergeron Clifford LLP If you or a loved one has suffered an injury, contact us at 877-391-2923 or fill out our online form below. With office locations across the East Region and a clientele that often has mobility issues, we are prepared to work wherever is most convenient for you. If you need us to visit you at your home or hospital, we can do that too.

We can help you. Get started now

Bold labels are required.

Contact Information
disclaimer.

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an lawyer-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.

close

Privacy Policy

Visit One of Our Conveniently Located Offices Today Schedule your free appointment: 877-391-2923

Kingston Office
1 Hyperion Ct.
Kingston, ON K7K 7G3

Toll Free: 877-391-2923
Fax: 613-384-0501
Kingston Law Office Map

Ottawa Office
185 Somerset Street West, Suite 305
Ottawa, ON K2P 0J2

Toll Free: 877-391-2923
Fax: 613-241-6381
Ottawa Law Office Map

Whitby Office
173 Brock St. N., Suite 104
Whitby, ON L1N 4H3

Toll Free: 877-391-2923
Fax: 905-426-8574
Whitby Law Office Map

Perth Office
31 Foster St.
Perth, ON K7H 1R5

Toll Free: 877-391-2923
Phone: 613-267-4313
Fax: 613-267-4852
Map & Directions

Carleton Place Office
164 Bridge Street
Carleton Place, ON K7C 2V7

Phone: 613-257-5887
Fax: 613-257-5889
Map & Directions

We can help you. Get started now »